Why Emotional Calls Hit Police Officers Hardest
Key Takeaways
For many police officers, calls that pose no physical threat - arriving at a child abuse scene, responding to an overdose, discovering a suicide - are often more psychologically damaging than high-danger situations
Police training prepares officers for physical and cognitive demands, but there is no realistic way to emotionally prepare someone for witnessing innocent people in their darkest moments
Officers who pride themselves on performing under pressure often struggle most with these calls, because they don’t fit the mental model of what they signed up to handle
Even as police culture becomes more open about mental health, many officers still interpret their own emotional reactions as weakness or incompetence, which deepens the cycle of trauma
The goal of therapy is not to eliminate difficult emotions but to help officers recognize them, use them as information, and make more conscious decisions in response
Processing rather than suppressing difficult feelings can actually build greater resilience and calm under pressure over time
When I started providing therapy for police officers, I assumed their most disturbing experiences would involve threats to their own safety: bar fights, active shootings, gang violence.
I was surprised to learn that arriving in the aftermath of tragedies was often more impactful than being thrown into live chaos. Meeting a child harmed by their parents may haunt them for years. Reporting to an overdose may send them into depression.
In this post, I discuss why these types of incidents, rather than ones posing immediate risk to the officers themselves, can have the most devastating psychological consequences.
You Can’t Teach This
To become a police officer, recruits go through rigorous physical and cognitive training. They are put through simulations in which split-second decisions are made in response to rapidly changing circumstances, all while following intricate protocols and legal precedents.
However, it’s hard to imagine how even the ideal police academy could emotionally prepare someone to comfort an abused child or discover a suicide. These are situations most of us can scarcely imagine, let alone cope with.
Many police officers pursue their line of work because they have always thrived under pressure and are fearless in danger. They often anticipate, and indeed report enjoying, the adrenaline rush of containing a violent situation. None of them look forward to seeing innocent people in their darkest hours.
Changing Culture
In recent years, police leadership have increased support for officers after these distressing calls. There is also more open conversation than ever before about the psychological burden they carry.
But no matter how much their community normalizes negative reactions to these circumstances, cops may still criticize themselves for experiencing inner turmoil. They may see it as a sign of weakness, that they’re not cut out for the job.
This creates a vicious cycle in which an officer becomes increasingly traumatized by subsequent events, avoids seeking help due to internal shame, and sees his accumulated symptoms as further signs of incompetence.
How Therapy Shifts Perspective
Since first responders see their negative emotions as obstacles to success, they may come to therapy looking to extinguish them.
What I try to impart is that feelings themselves are not the problem; it’s how we manage them that counts. Through our work together, they learn to recognize challenging emotions, use them as signals rather than roadblocks, and make conscious decisions in response. By recognizing their feelings rather than suppressing them, they can develop resilience, self-confidence and even greater calm under pressure than when we started.
If you’re a first responder looking to improve your emotional toolkit, please feel free to reach out for a consultation. Your feelings make sense; let’s make them work in your favour.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
It makes sense. Officers who thrive under physical pressure are often conditioned to manage threat through action. Calls that involve witnessing suffering rather than responding to danger don’t offer that same outlet. There’s nothing to contain or neutralize, only something to absorb. That’s a fundamentally different psychological experience, and struggling with it isn’t a sign of weakness.
-
No. The approaches I use, particularly CBT and Cognitive Processing Therapy, are structured and goal-oriented. The focus is on understanding how these experiences are affecting your thoughts and emotions now, and building practical tools to manage them. You won’t be asked to recount difficult calls before you’re ready, and the pace is always yours to set.
-
That’s exactly what therapy for first responders is designed to do. The goal isn’t to make you more emotional'; it’s to help you recognize what you’re feeling, process it rather than carry it, and make clearer decisions as a result. Most officers I work with find that addressing their emotional responses actually improves their performance rather than interfering with it.